Academic Writing - Logical Fallacies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words

Academic Writing - Logical Fallacies - Essay ExampleThe question that Why put one acrosst you bed me? is an example of this as Marissa is assuming, by the nature of her question, that her begetter does not love her, asking him why he does not. As Archie (2009) notes, the assumption of the complex question can totally be known from the context. non all cases where something not generally granted is assumed are fallacious because not all much(prenominal) passages involve arguments. Clearly, there is no good way to respond directly to the question being posed, only to identify the presupposition or assumption of the question. A corrected version of this question might be If you love me, why wont you let me use the car. This corrected version of the question focuses back on the issue of the car, and away from whether or not her father loves her.This is an example of a straw man, which as Kahane (2005) writes, involves a misrepresentation of an opponents position, or a competitors p roduct, or goes after a weaker opponent or competitor while ignoring a stronger one. The argument Marissa is using is anHer Dad looked at her lovingly, No, Marissa, I dont regard youre a child. I just dont think its safe for you to drive the car to a party. She snapped, Because its not safe? Well, you better take away our kitchen knives, because they arent safeexample of a straw man because it misrepresents her opponents, her fathers position on the issue. Because the two people know each other well, Marissa can anticipate her fathers objection, which she mischaracterizes to serve her own purposes. Like an advertiser misrepresenting the competitions products and services (Kahane), Marissa has constructed a out of true reality in which her opponent makes a bad argument. To correct her mistake, Marissa ought to incorporate the possibility that her father does not think she is a child by starting her sentence with an if, like in the following If you dont think I am a child, let me t ake